| Father Bernard Cullen (January 5, 1942) |
| Father Francis Ferrara (February 23, 1945) |
| Father Daniel Lenihan (May 17, 1946) |
| Brother Walter Schoenberg (August 31, 1946) |
| Father Thomas McCarty (September 12, 1947) |
| Father Kenneth Tietjen (August 18, 1948) |
| Father Lawrence Nolan (August 4, 1949) |
| Father James O'Connor (August 18, 1949) |
| Father Thaddeus Kennedy (September 24, 1949) |
| Father Xavier Dieter (March 24, 1950) |
| Brother Felix Leja (May 24, 1950) |
| Father Thomas MacMaster (June 13, 1950) |
| Father David Wechter (August 11, 1951) |
| Father John Janinski (July 23, 1953) |
| Father James Henderson (August 14, 1953) |
| Brother Placid Zilka (March 27, 1955) |
| Father Stephen Verbest (October 4, 1957) |
| Brother Paul Halaburt (January 7, 1958) |
| Father Brendan Freeman (Abbot) (August 13, 1958) |
|
| Brother Tobias Shanahan (December 15, 1958) |
| Brother Kevin Knox (February 14, 1959) |
| Brother Gilbert Cardillo (June 1, 1961) |
| Brother Robert Simon (August 9, 1962) |
| Father David Bock (October 25, 1962) |
| Brother John O'Driscoll (January 3, 1963) |
| Father Neil Paquette (February 3, 1975) |
| Father Alberic Farbolin (April 29, 1984) |
| Brother Ephrem Poppish (December 5, 1984) |
| Brother Dennis Vavra (February 27, 1990) |
| Brother Albert Bracket (April 4, 1993) |
| Brother Paul Andrew Tanner (November 27, 1998) |
| Brother Jonah Wharff (January 18, 2000) |
| Brother Joseph Kronebusch (January 6, 2008) |
Brother Nicholas Koenig (August 15, 2008) |
Brother Michael Gajarski (November 22, 2009) |
Brother Juan Diego Lavado (March 25, 2010) |
Brother Eugene Hinksmon (May 31, 2009) |
|